What to look for in handmade candy
The best clues are the feel of the first bite and the flavor that lingers afterward. Hand-cut edges and slightly varied sizes are part of a small batch; the chew or snap should still be recognizable from piece to piece.
- Vanilla caramel: Look for an even amber color and a soft chew at room temperature. Salt should lift the vanilla, not cover up the butter.
- Maple pecan brittle: A thin shard should break cleanly. The pecans should taste toasted, with maple coming through in the finish.
- Peppermint bark: Look for distinct dark and white chocolate layers and a firm snap. Crushed peppermint should leave a cool finish.
- Cherry candy drops: A smooth, glossy surface and a shift from sweet to tart are the hallmarks of this hard candy.
Store each candy by texture
A cool, dry cupboard is a good starting point. Use clean, airtight candy tins and keep them out of direct sun and away from strong odors. Follow the keeping and best-by directions printed on the candy’s own label.
- Sea Salt Vanilla Caramels
- Leave on the individual wax-paper wraps. Let cool caramels soften at room temperature before serving.
- Maple Pecan Brittle
- Close the tin promptly. Humidity makes a good crisp shard sticky.
- Dark Chocolate Peppermint Bark
- Keep away from heat. Separate layers with clean parchment to protect the chocolate surface.
- Tart Cherry Candy Drops
- Keep in their own airtight container so the drops stay dry and separate.
Check ingredients before sharing
The vanilla caramel style uses dairy; pecan brittle features tree nuts; and peppermint bark with white chocolate typically contains milk. Chocolate may also contain soy lecithin. For any of the four styles, use the actual ingredient label and ask about shared equipment when choosing candy for someone with an allergy.
If you’re putting together a candy gift, keep the ingredient information with each style so the recipient can check it before tasting.
Set out a small tasting plate
Try a soft caramel and a piece of bark side by side after dinner: buttery vanilla first, cool peppermint second. Put brittle in its own dry dish and set the cherry drops out whole. For a host gift, separate candy styles with their own tins or snug wrappers rather than mixing textures in one container.
Compare the four reserve candies.
Compare Options